Ice Cream

Current flavors are subject to change

You’ll love the pure, frozen joy of Cedar Crest Ice Cream! Made locally in nearby Manitowoc, Cedar Crest is made in small batches with the finest premium ingredients to create the best experience for our customers. Crazy Sweet boasts 16 different varieties of premium Cedar Crest ice cream. Try a delicious root beer float - vanilla ice cream paired with home brewed in Appleton Stone Arch root beer. Love sundaes? We are your destination! 12 fun, original creations like Breakfast in America (maple syrup, bacon and waffle cone), The Dirty Worm (gummy worms, chocolate syrup and Oreo cookies), or the Turtle Cheesecake (cheesecake pieces, caramel syrup and pecans) are fresh, fun and utterly delicious.

 
Blueberry Waffle Cone

Blueberry Waffle Cone

Chocolate Covered Waffle Cone Pieces in Blueberry flavored Ice Cream with a Blueberry swirl

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Elephant Tracks

Elephant Tracks

Pieces of Peanut Butter Cups and Chocolate Fudge Swirled in Chocolate Ice Cream

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Cotton Candy

Cotton Candy

Cotton Candy flavored Ice Cream with a Cotton Candy Swirl

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Caramel Collision

Caramel Collision

Caramel Ice Cream with a Caramel Swirl and Chocolate Coated Caramel Mini Cups

Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Cookie Monster

COOKIE MONSTER

Cookie Dough pieces and Chocolate Sandwich Cookie pieces blended in Cookie Dough flavored Ice Cream

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Superman

Superman

Blue Raspberry, Cherry and Vanilla flavored ice cream

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Mackinac Island Fudge

Mackinac Island Fudge

Vanilla Ice Cream with Chewy Fudge Pieces and Swirled with Butter Fudge Sauce

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Coconut Explosion

Coconut Explosion

Coconut flavored Ice Cream with Chocolate Covered Coconut Pieces, Coconut Flakes and Chocolate Covered Almonds

Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Praline and Pecan

Praline Pecan

Butterscotch Fudge Swirled in Vanilla Ice Cream mixed with Praline Pecans

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Strawberry

Strawberry

Strawberry flavored Ice Cream swirled with Real Strawberries

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint Chocolate Chip

Green Mint flavored Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Pirate's Bounty

Pirate's Bounty

M & M's® Chocolate Candies and Chocolate Sandwich Cookies in Caramel flavored Ice Cream

Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Playdough

Playdough

Blue Moon Ice Cream sprinkled with Multi-Colored Cookie Dough Pieces

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Vanilla

DELUXE Vanilla

Vanilla flavored Ice Cream

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Zanzibar Chocolate

Zanzibar Chocolate

Dark Chocolate flavored Ice Cream

 
Crazy Sweet Appleton Candy Store Ice Cream Cedar Crest Rainbow Sherbet

Rainbow Sherbet

Lime, Orange, and Raspberry flavored Sherbets swirled together